5 Reasons Not To Share Custody And The Truth That Trumps It All
Share on Tumblr
By Karen Covy, Featured DM Blogger - June 30, 2015 - Updated December 02, 2016

Fotolia_69354043_XS.jpgWhen it comes to custody, the Internet is full of half-truths and muddy information. Google the word “shared custody” and you will find some articles stating that it means joint custody and equal parenting time and other articles stating it means equal parenting time, but not joint custody, and still others that claim it means joint custody but not necessarily equal parenting time!

What Shared Custody Really Is

There are two aspects to custody: legal custody (which is your right to make important parenting decisions regarding your kids) and physical or residential custody (which where your child lives and spends his/her time.) “Shared” custody typically refers to physical custody: it means that two parents share approximately equal time with their child. Put another way, it means that a child spends roughly equal amounts of time living with each parent.

Is Shared Custody in Your Child’s Best Interest?

Like every good lawyer, I will tell you that the answer to that question is: it depends. It depends upon how old your child is, what your child’s temperament is, and how far you and your ex live from each other. In general, traditional wisdom states that the younger your child is, the less emotionally secure your child is and the farther you and your ex live from each other, the harder shared custody will be on your child.

Here are 5 reasons shared custody might not be in your child’s best interest.

1. Young Children Are Not Ping Pong Balls. Bouncing from one home to another can be extremely disruptive, especially for very small kids. Infants, toddlers, and even young children, who shuffle back and forth between their parents’ houses often have no real sense of “home.” They often have difficulty adjusting to shared custody, and may feel like they have “Mom’s house,” and “Dad’s house,” but no home of their own.

2. Having Two “Homes” Places Added Stress on Kids. It forces them to keep track of everything they own all the time. Trust me, that never happens. Inevitably, your kids are going to leave their favorite shirt, or their soccer shoes, or their homework at their other parent’s house when they want or need it. Unless you have enough money to buy your kids two sets of everything, you better be prepared to make a lot of last minute runs to your ex’s house to pick up what your kids forgot.

3. Unless You and Your Ex Live Very Close to Each Other, Your Children are Going to Spend a Lot of Time in the Car. Commuting is not fun for anyone. Its even less fun when you are a child and have absolutely no voice in the matter. Having to constantly travel back and forth between two homes (especially if you are doing it every couple of days) wastes an enormous amount of time and energy.

4. If 50/50 Parenting Time Just Means Your Kid Spends More Time in Day Care and Less Time With a Parent, That Doesn’t Make Sense. If one parent has a crazy work schedule, but wants equal parenting time, what really happens is that the kids end up spending a good portion of their scheduled “parenting time” in daycare, after school care or with babysitters, rather than with their other parent. Having “shared custody” in this situation is clearly not about trying to do what is best for the kids. Shared custody only works if both parents actually spend their parenting time with their kids.

5. If Parents Don’t Get Along, Shared Custody is a Nightmare. Studies have repeatedly shown that the one thing that damages children the most is conflict. If you and your ex are constantly fighting, and can not agree on anything, then trying to equally share parenting time, decisions, and responsibilities is going to do nothing more than throw everyone into never-ending battle. It will be exhausting, stressful, and destructive.

Is Shared Custody a Bad Idea?

Again, the answer to this question is: it depends! Study after study shows that children do best when both parents are involved in their lives. Studies also show that the amount of time children spend with a parent affects the quality of the child’s relationship with that parent. So, even though spending equal time with each parent may be stressful, difficult, and expensive, if it means that your child will have a deeper bond with both parents, and will be happier, more well-adjusted, and more successful in life in the long run, then sharing custody makes all the sense in the world.

But, there is one HUGE problem with this entire discussion.

The Truth About Shared Custody

“Custody,” whether you’re talking about shared custody, joint custody, sole custody, physical custody or anything else, is more of a discussion about the PARENTS than it is about the CHILDREN.

What is in the best interest of your children? Here is the truth: I don’t know! And neither does your lawyer, or the judge, or your friendly state legislator! Oh, we all probably have an opinion about it. But who is to say that our opinion is right?

If you want to know the truth about shared custody, the one single truth that I know for sure, it is this: Every case is different. Every child is different. Every family is different. Shared parenting time may allow one child to flourish and cause another child to flounder. Armed with the best intentions, and the latest research, the “officials” involved in your divorce case may end up doing things that are not even close to being in your children’s best interest.

What’s the best solution? Make the decision yourself. Listen to your children. Focus on your children. Put your own ego aside. Talk to your ex. (Yes, I understand that this one is hard. But doing the hard things is what being a good parent is really about!) Be willing to make mistakes, and then to do things differently. Maybe shared custody will work great for your kids. Maybe it won’t. Maybe it won’t work now, but may work when your kids get older. Who knows? The truth is, you probably won’t know either until you try.

For more divorce advice and information from Karen Covy go to http://karencovy.com.

Related Articles:

Share on Tumblr
Recommended For You
10 Things to Consider When Negotiating Child Support

How to successfully negotiate the best amount of child support and what pitfalls to avoid. What else to included in these negotiations.

Custody Battles: Are They Worth the Fight?

I've been sort of following Gossip Girl star Kelly Rutherford's custody battle saga. I say "sort of" because hearing about any custody battle...

Birdnesting Custody: Hooray for Alternative Custody Arrangements

A friend gave me this great advice: your divorce doesn’t have to be like anyone else's and neither does your custody arrangement.

Around The Web
Comments 6 Comments

Enter the text you see in the image.

 Wants YOU...
To Become A Contributor
DivorcedMoms Direct

Subscribe to our FREE newsletter!